The finale of Peter Weber’s season of The Bachelor was nothing short of dramatic, leaving viewers on the edge of their seats. Initially, it seemed like a fairytale ending when Peter proposed to Hannah Ann Sluss. However, the journey took a sharp turn, leading to a breakup and a rekindled connection with Madison Prewett. Let’s delve into the rollercoaster of events and uncover exactly Who Did Peter Weber Choose On The Bachelor.
At the start of the final episode, Madison Prewett had left, seemingly eliminating herself from the competition due to differing lifestyles and values. This left Hannah Ann as the last woman standing, and seemingly, Peter’s obvious choice. The episode began with Hannah Ann remaining, creating the initial impression that she was indeed the one Peter would choose.
[Peter Weber’s tumultuous journey on The Bachelor came to a shocking conclusion. ]
The Proposal to Hannah Ann and the Immediate Regret
After Madison’s departure, Peter was left to navigate his feelings and ultimately decided to propose to Hannah Ann. In a seemingly romantic proposal filmed in Australia, Peter declared his love for Hannah Ann. He expressed, “My heart chooses you forever. I love you, Hannah Ann, and the love that you’ve shown me is all that I have ever wanted. And I never want to let you go.” Hannah Ann accepted, and for a brief moment, it appeared Peter Weber had found his happy ending on The Bachelor.
[Peter Weber proposes to Hannah Ann Sluss in a scene from The Bachelor finale.]
However, the happiness was short-lived. Just a month later, when Hannah Ann visited Peter in Los Angeles, the facade crumbled. Peter confessed he was still struggling emotionally and couldn’t fully commit to their relationship. He broke off the engagement, leaving Hannah Ann devastated and questioning his sincerity. This dramatic turn of events became a central point in understanding who Peter Weber truly wanted on The Bachelor.
Hannah Ann’s Confrontation: “You Took Away My First Engagement”
The breakup with Hannah Ann was far from amicable. When they met face-to-face to discuss the split, Hannah Ann did not hold back her emotions. She felt “blindsided” and accused Peter of knowing exactly what to say to keep her invested in the relationship. She powerfully stated, “You took away from me my first engagement. You took that away from me.”
[Hannah Ann confronts Peter Weber during their emotional breakup after The Bachelor engagement.]
Hannah Ann’s poignant words highlighted the emotional turmoil and the perceived lack of respect she experienced. She questioned Peter’s intentions and the weight of his words, famously advising him, “If you want to be with a woman, you need to become a real man.” This confrontation became a defining moment of the finale, emphasizing the chaotic nature of Peter’s choices.
Madison’s Return and a Non-Committal “Relationship”
Despite initially letting Madison go, Peter’s journey wasn’t over. In a move that shocked many viewers, Madison returned during the live portion of the finale. It was revealed that Peter’s feelings for Madison persisted even after his engagement to Hannah Ann. This revelation further complicated the question of who Peter Weber would ultimately choose on The Bachelor.
Peter explained to Madison, “We’ve both been really hurt, extremely hurt and been through the ringer with all of this. I know there is a lot of healing that both of us have to do but I know the love and the respect I have for you, and that has never changed.” While they expressed their continued affection for each other, Peter did not propose to Madison. Instead, they stated they would take their relationship “day by day,” leaving the future uncertain.
[Madison Prewett and Peter Weber discuss their relationship status during The Bachelor finale live special.]
Barb Weighs In: Team Hannah Ann
Adding another layer of drama was the strong opinion of Peter’s mother, Barbara “Barb” Weber. Barb made it abundantly clear that she was firmly in “Team Hannah Ann.” She expressed disappointment that Peter did not end up with Hannah Ann, stating, “As a mother, that wasn’t what we were expecting. When I said I wanted Hannah Ann so badly, it’s because we just clicked right away. Unfortunately, we did not have that connection with Madison.”
[Peter Weber’s parents, especially his mother Barb, expressed strong opinions during The Bachelor finale.]
Barb’s preference for Hannah Ann stemmed from a perceived stronger connection and Hannah Ann’s immediate acceptance by the family. She contrasted this with Madison, recounting a rocky first meeting and Madison’s hesitancy about a quick engagement. Barb’s vocal disapproval of Madison added significant tension to Peter and Madison’s attempt to pursue a relationship.
Conclusion: A Choice of Uncertainty
Ultimately, who did Peter Weber choose on The Bachelor? The answer is complicated. Initially, he chose Hannah Ann, proposing and committing to her. However, this choice proved fleeting as his unresolved feelings for Madison led to the engagement’s demise. In the end, Peter did not definitively “choose” either woman in a traditional Bachelor sense. He ended his season engaged to no one, embarking on a tentative, undefined relationship with Madison amidst family disapproval and public scrutiny. The finale was a testament to the unpredictable nature of love and reality television, leaving viewers to ponder the true outcome of Peter Weber’s Bachelor journey.
