Peter Weber’s season of “The Bachelor” was nothing short of a rollercoaster, culminating in a finale that left Bachelor Nation in complete disbelief. As the dramatic season 24 drew to a close, viewers were on the edge of their seats to discover: Who Did Peter From The Bachelor End Up With? The journey to finding out was filled with twists, turns, and unprecedented family drama.
At the beginning of the final episode, the landscape seemed set. Hannah Ann Sluss remained, poised to potentially become Peter’s fiancée, while Madison Prewett had made the difficult decision to leave. However, as this season proved time and again, nothing was predictable.
The finale’s first night showcased the traditional meeting of the families. Both Hannah Ann and Madison met Peter’s parents, and it became immediately clear where the Weber family’s preferences lay. Peter’s parents, especially his mother Barbara, connected deeply with Hannah Ann, expressing fervent wishes for Peter to choose her. Barbara’s emotional plea to “bring her home” quickly became a viral moment, highlighting the family’s strong affection for Hannah Ann. Despite his family’s clear favoritism, Peter’s heart appeared to still be conflicted, particularly regarding Madison.
The following day brought a pivotal moment. Madison, grappling with their fundamental differences and future compatibility, decided to have a crucial conversation with Peter. She articulated her concerns, stating that their differing expectations and perspectives might create insurmountable challenges. “We see things so differently. We expect such different things,” Madison explained, emphasizing her belief that forcing their relationship would be detrimental to both of them. Ultimately, Madison made the heartbreaking choice to remove herself from the competition, declaring, “I don’t know that we can give each other what we need.” Despite Peter’s confusion and protestations, Madison departed, seemingly solidifying Hannah Ann’s position as the final choice.
With Madison gone, Hannah Ann remained, expressing her unwavering love and seeking reassurance from Peter about his feelings. However, Peter’s responses lacked the certainty Hannah Ann desired, leaving her understandably apprehensive about the final rose ceremony.
Tuesday night’s episode unveiled even more drama. Despite her reservations, Hannah Ann arrived at the final rose ceremony. Peter, having just navigated Madison’s departure, proceeded to propose to a visibly emotional Hannah Ann. He declared his love and commitment, saying, “My heart chooses you forever. I love you, Hannah Ann.” Hannah Ann accepted, and for a brief moment, it seemed Peter had found his happy ending.
However, the fairytale was short-lived. Just a month later, when Hannah Ann visited Peter in Los Angeles, the cracks in their engagement became chasms. Peter confessed he was still struggling with unresolved feelings and could not fully commit to their relationship. He broke off the engagement, leaving Hannah Ann devastated and heartbroken. She poignantly stated, “You took away from me my first engagement. You took that away from me,” highlighting the profound impact of Peter’s change of heart.
The live “After the Final Rose” special brought a raw and intense confrontation between Peter and Hannah Ann. Hannah Ann confronted Peter directly about his mixed signals and lack of transparency. She powerfully expressed her feelings of betrayal, questioning his sincerity and the weight of his words during the proposal. “Either you don’t mean what you say or you don’t understand the weight of your words and how they impact people, so which one is it?” she challenged him. Hannah Ann’s strength and composure resonated with viewers as she delivered a parting message to Peter: “If you want to be with a woman, you need to become a real man.”
Adding another layer of complexity, Peter’s mother, Barbara, voiced her strong disapproval of Madison and her continued support for Hannah Ann during the live special. Barbara openly criticized Madison’s interactions with the family and emphasized her instant connection with Hannah Ann. “When I said I wanted Hannah Ann so badly, it’s because we just clicked right away. Unfortunately, we did not have that connection with Madison,” Barbara stated, making her preference unequivocally clear. She further detailed perceived slights from Madison, including making the family wait and not expressing being “madly in love” with Peter.
Madison, given the opportunity to respond, remained composed and true to herself, stating, “I came into this journey and I said I was going to be unashamed of who I am and undeniably be myself. And that is something I’ve done throughout this entire journey.”
In a final twist, after his breakup with Hannah Ann and amidst his family’s disapproval of Madison, Peter revealed that he wanted to pursue a relationship with Madison again. Madison rejoined Peter on stage, and they stated they would be taking their relationship “day by day.” So, to answer the burning question: who did Peter from The Bachelor end up with? Technically, Peter ended up with Madison, choosing to pursue a relationship with her after ending his engagement to Hannah Ann. However, they did not get engaged during the finale, and the future of their relationship remained uncertain, especially given the significant family friction. Peter’s journey concluded not with a clear-cut engagement, but with a complicated and unresolved romantic future with Madison, leaving viewers to wonder what would happen next for this Bachelor couple.
