The age-old debate continues: cats or dogs, which makes the better pet? It’s a question pondered by households worldwide. Forget personal biases, let’s delve into the scientific evidence to find an objective answer. As your impartial judge, I’ll analyze the facts, weighing the pros and cons of cat and dog ownership across key categories to deliver a verdict grounded in science. To settle this definitively, we’ll evaluate “best pet” across five crucial aspects:
- Which pet brings people the most happiness?
- Which pet poses a greater danger to humans?
- Which pet is more environmentally friendly?
- Which pet is easier to care for?
- Which pet offers the most benefits beyond companionship?
For each category, we’ll explore scientific research to determine whether cats (Felis catus) or dogs (Canis familiaris) come out on top.
Two pets looking at each other, a golden retriever dog on the left and a tabby cat on the right, posing the question of which one is the better pet.
The Happiness Factor: Which Pet Makes People Happier?
Pet ownership generally enhances life satisfaction. A Croatian survey revealed that over half of pet owners consider their cat or dog a paramount family member—even more so than spouses, parents, or children! Furthermore, research indicates that spending a mere $5 on pet treats or toys generates more happiness than spending the same amount on oneself or loved ones. Direct comparisons between pet owners and non-pet owners suggest pets generally increase life satisfaction, though not always happiness. Intriguingly, pet owners might actually be less happy than those without pets, despite believing pets boost their happiness – a concept known as the “pet-effect paradox.”
So, between cats and dogs, which brings more joy? A Mexican study directly comparing cat and dog owners found that individuals reported “greater emotional closeness” with dogs, signifying stronger social support, companionship, and unconditional love. Cats, however, were perceived as “less expensive, less demanding, and less restrictive,” leading to the conclusion that cat-owner relationships were “better overall” based on practicality.
However, a “better” relationship based on cost and convenience doesn’t equate to a happier one. My office chair is arguably a “better” relationship financially than my daughter, but it certainly doesn’t bring the same happiness. Only one study specifically examined “happiness” (termed “wellbeing”) and concluded that, after accounting for personality and baseline happiness, “dog owners had higher wellbeing.” Essentially, regardless of your personality or happiness level, dog ownership is statistically linked to greater happiness than cat ownership. Science points to dogs as the champions of happiness in this round.
Danger to Humans: Which Pet is More Risky?
Pets affect our physical health in both positive and negative ways. Dog owners are demonstrably more active, spending significantly more time outdoors walking. Dog owners average 300 minutes of dog walking weekly, 200 minutes more than non-dog owners. However, these walks also contribute to injuries. In the U.S., nearly 87,000 people visit emergency rooms annually due to pet-related trips and falls, with dog-related incidents being 7.5 times more frequent than cat-related ones. Over 20% of these injuries involved dogs pulling or pushing their owners while walking. Dog walking, while beneficial, carries inherent risks.
Then there are disease and infection risks. Rabies, though preventable with vaccination, is more commonly associated with dogs. Toxoplasma gondii, a parasite found in cat feces, can be ingested by humans, posing risks particularly to pregnant women and those with compromised immune systems. Rabies remains deadly, causing tens of thousands of deaths yearly, with 99% attributed to rabies-infected dogs. Toxoplasmosis is widespread, infecting almost 50% globally, but is rarely fatal in healthy individuals.
However, the most significant human health impact comes from dog bites. The U.S. records approximately 4.5 million dog bites annually, leading to over 300,000 ER visits and about 35 deaths per year. Pet-related injuries, predominantly from dog attacks, have been found to be as detrimental to human health as smoking, excessive alcohol consumption, illegal drug use, or obesity.
While cat-related injuries occur, primarily from trips or scratches, dogs are undeniably the more dangerous pet to human health. Cats take the win in this category.
Environmental Impact: Which Pet is Greener?
Pet food production has substantial environmental consequences. Estimates suggest 56–151 million tons of CO2 are released annually in pet food production, representing about 3% of global agricultural emissions. This significant footprint is largely due to the meat content in pet food. Dog food, typically higher in meat, is more environmentally taxing than cat food. A study concluded that “dog food emissions intensity was 1.6 times that of cat food.”
However, when considering ecological damage, cats are the primary concern. Cats, both feral and domestic roaming outdoors, are relentless hunters of wildlife. In the United States, cats are considered “the single greatest source of anthropogenic mortality for US birds and mammals.” The wildlife destruction caused by domestic cats dwarfs even human hunting and habitat destruction. Studies estimate “free-ranging domestic cats kill 1.3–4.0 billion birds and 6.3–22.3 billion mammals annually” in the US alone. Additionally, cats kill up to 871 million reptiles and 320 million amphibians each year in the US. The IUCN Red List attributes cats to 14% of recorded mammal, bird, and reptile extinctions.
In terms of environmental impact, dogs are the clear winner.
Ease of Care: Which Pet is Less Demanding?
This category is inherently subjective, focusing on which pet requires less time and effort for basic needs.
Feeding is comparable for both cats and dogs. Pet food is readily available, and feeding involves simply dispensing food into a bowl. Feeding schedules can be tailored to the owner’s preference.
However, waste management differs significantly. Dogs require outdoor bathroom breaks, demanding owner involvement and time. This is in addition to regular walks for exercise and mental well-being. While beneficial for human health, these walks are time-consuming and not always “easy.” Cats, conversely, utilize litter boxes—a relatively low-effort system. Weekly litter box maintenance might take 30 minutes, compared to the 300 minutes per week dedicated to dog walks.
Furthermore, cats are often perceived as more independent. The average cat generally requires less attention and affection than a dog. Cats can be left alone for longer periods without negative emotional consequences or destructive behavior due to separation anxiety. Dogs typically need more social interaction, often physical, which can be demanding.
Overall, cats require less physical and emotional input from their owners. Cats are the easier pet to care for.
Benefits Beyond Companionship: Which Pet Offers More to the World?
The score is currently tied: two categories for cats, two for dogs, making this final category decisive.
Domestic cats originated from a Middle Eastern wildcat, domesticated approximately 12,000 years ago. Their relationship with humans began with agriculture, as cats controlled rodent populations attracted to grain stores. They accompanied humans across Europe, primarily as pest control in barns and ships, not as indoor companions. Only in the 19th century did cats transition into household pets. Historically, cats were crucial for human civilization due to their hunting prowess, protecting food supplies and enabling population growth.
Dogs have played an even more profound and ancient role in human history. Domesticated around 23,000 years ago from Siberian wolves, dogs assisted humans with hunting and protection even before agriculture. Humans and dogs have collaborated since the last Ice Age, with canine companionship undeniably contributing to human success.
Unlike cats, dogs have diversified into numerous roles beyond companionship in modern society. Service dogs assist individuals with visual impairments, mobility challenges, and hearing loss. They are trained to detect seizures, provide support during medical episodes, and serve in military and police forces globally, detecting explosives, contraband, and apprehending criminals. Search and rescue dogs locate individuals lost in wilderness or trapped in disasters. Therapy dogs offer emotional support in homes, hospitals, and care facilities. Dogs continue to aid in hunting and farming, herding livestock, retrieving game, finding truffles, and even lobster hunting. Dogs can even track whales by scenting their feces and detect spoiled wine or cancer in humans. Dogs offer a far wider range of non-pet related assistance to humanity compared to cats. Dogs gain the advantage in this final category.
Final Verdict: Dogs are the Better Pet (Objectively)
With a 3-2 victory, dogs are scientifically determined to be the “better” pet overall.
A note to cat lovers: As a cat enthusiast myself, I understand the appeal of feline companionship. Personally, I often prefer cats. Dogs can be demanding and overly enthusiastic. However, these are subjective preferences. Individual needs vary, and cats may be ideal pets for many. Objectively analyzing pet ownership across societies and history, however, reveals dogs as the superior pet.
While you may disagree with the categories or their weighting, these five areas were chosen to reflect key aspects of pet ownership. Frankly, I anticipated a cat victory and was surprised by the results.
This exercise highlights an important lesson: evidence should guide our conclusions, even when they challenge personal beliefs. Therefore, based on the evidence, dogs are declared the better pet. Dog lovers, enjoy your victory – on paper, you win. But in my heart, cats still hold a special place.
A person petting a cat, highlighting the personal connection and affection many feel for their feline companions, despite the objective conclusion favoring dogs.
Thanks for reading The Narwhal Diaries! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.
