Peanut butter is a much-loved treat for dogs. It’s perfect for stuffing into Kongs, disguising pills, or spreading on lick mats to keep your furry friend entertained. Freezing these peanut butter-filled goodies extends the fun, turning treat time into a delightful, long-lasting experience for most dogs.
However, it’s crucial to understand that not all peanut butter is created equal when it comes to canine consumption. As a responsible dog owner, ensuring you choose a peanut butter that is safe for your beloved pet is paramount.
This guide will walk you through identifying dog-safe peanut butter brands, highlighting what to look for on the label, and warning you about the dangerous ingredients to avoid.
Identifying Dog-Safe Peanut Butter: Key Ingredients to Look For
When selecting peanut butter for your dog, natural is best. Opt for peanut butter that is free from added sugars and artificial sweeteners, especially xylitol. Ideally, the label should indicate “no added salt” or “unsalted.”
Avoid peanut butter that lists preservatives, hydrogenated vegetable oils, or added sugars among its ingredients.
Dog-safe peanut butter should have a simple ingredient list, ideally containing only peanuts and possibly a small amount of salt.
Xylitol, sometimes deceptively labeled as “birch sugar,” is an extremely toxic ingredient for dogs. Always scrutinize the ingredient list for both “xylitol” and “birch sugar.”
The Serious Risks of Xylitol and Birch Sugar
Xylitol is a sugar substitute commonly found in sugar-free products like chewing gum, candies, and even some brands of peanut butter marketed as “sugar-free.” It is vital to never purchase sugar-free peanut butter for your dog, as xylitol is highly poisonous to them.
If a dog consumes xylitol, it can lead to severe health issues, including:
- Hypoglycemia (dangerously low blood sugar)
- Seizures
- Liver failure
- In severe cases, death
Immediate veterinary attention is crucial if you suspect your dog has ingested xylitol. This toxic substance can be absorbed into the bloodstream very quickly, leading to rapid and serious health complications.
Related reading: Birch Sugar: The Deadly Ingredient Hiding in Plain Sight
Recommended Dog-Safe Peanut Butter Brands
Dog Lab, a respected product review company specializing in pet products, conducted extensive testing on over 50 peanut butter brands to identify the healthiest and safest options for dogs. Their methodology includes surveying dog owners and consulting with veterinarians, canine nutritionists, and animal behaviorists.
Dog Lab’s top recommendation for the best peanut butter for dogs is Whole Foods’ 365 brand smooth peanut butter. 365 Everyday Value Organic Peanut Butter stands out as a safe choice due to its single ingredient: peanuts!
Simplicity is key. This peanut butter contains no unnecessary salt, sugar, additives, or hard-to-pronounce ingredients. It’s simply 100% natural creamy peanut butter.
Trader Joe’s No Salt Peanut Butter is another excellent and budget-friendly option, mirroring the ingredient simplicity of the Whole Foods 365 brand.
For those dogs (and owners) who prefer a bit of texture, Teddie Super Chunky Peanut Butter was highlighted as the best crunchy peanut butter, safe for both humans and their canine companions.
Poochie Peanut Butter is also a noteworthy mention. Specifically formulated for dogs, this brand incorporates beneficial natural ingredients such as turmeric, flaxseed, parsley, and ginger to boost your dog’s health. Additionally, Poochie Peanut Butter donates 10% of its profits to animal shelters, making it a purchase that gives back.
For a comprehensive list of 16 tested and safe peanut butter options for dogs, you can visit DogLab.com.
List of Dog Safe Peanut Butter Brands:
- Whole Foods 365 Everyday Value Organic Peanut Butter
- Trader Joe’s Peanut Butter (No Salt)
- Teddie Super Chunky Peanut Butter
- Poochie Dog Peanut Butter
Moderation is Key
While peanut butter offers healthy fats, it’s important to feed it to your dog in moderation. Excessive fat intake and extra calories can contribute to obesity and potentially life-threatening pancreatitis. Even dog-safe peanut butter, when given in large quantities, can negatively impact your dog’s health.
Peanut Butter Brands to Absolutely Avoid for Your Dog
Many common peanut butter brands found on grocery store shelves contain unhealthy additives like trans fats, sweeteners, and other unnecessary ingredients. It’s crucial to avoid sharing these peanut butters with your dog.
Brands to avoid include:
- Skippy peanut butter
- Peter Pan peanut butter
- Jif peanut butter
- Nuts ‘n More
- Krush Nutrition
- Go Nuts Co
- Amazon brand/Happy Belly Peanut Butter
Just because a peanut butter is labeled “xylitol-free” doesn’t automatically make it dog-friendly. Some “natural” peanut butters, like Skippy Natural or Jif Natural peanut butter spread, while xylitol-free, are still not recommended due to additives such as corn syrup and trans fats.
Dog Lab also pointed out that some peanut butters marketed for pets are also not ideal. Kong Real Peanut Butter, for example, contains sugar and hydrogenated vegetable oil. Dog Butter includes palm oil in its ingredients.
Homemade Dog-Safe Peanut Butter: A Simple Recipe
Want complete control over the ingredients? Making your own homemade peanut butter is surprisingly easy!
You only need peanuts and a food processor.
Simply place peanuts (preferably unsalted) into a food processor and blend for up to 10 minutes, or until the mixture reaches a smooth consistency.
Making your own peanut butter ensures a healthy treat for your dog, as you have complete transparency about what goes into it.
Exploring Peanut Butter Alternatives for Dogs
Believe it or not, some dogs might not be peanut butter fans! Fortunately, there are many safe and delicious nut butter alternatives (and even nut-free options) to explore.
Almond butter, sunflower seed butter, and cashew butter are all safe alternatives for dogs, especially those with peanut allergies or dogs who simply don’t enjoy peanuts.
However, these alternatives are also high in fat and should be given in moderation. Remember that treats and snacks should only constitute about 10% of your dog’s daily diet. Their primary nutrition should come from their regular dog food.
For treat-stuffable options that aren’t nut-based, consider these healthy alternatives:
- Plain, low-fat Greek yogurt
- Cream cheese (in very small amounts due to fat content)
- Pumpkin puree (plain, unsweetened)
- Green beans (cooked or raw)
- Watermelon (seedless)
- Baby food (plain meat or vegetable-based, check ingredients for no onion or garlic)
Nuts to Keep Away From Dogs
Certain nuts are either unhealthy or toxic for dogs and should be strictly avoided:
- Hazelnuts
- Macadamia nuts
- Pecans
- Walnuts
- Pistachios
Top Dog Toys for Stuffing with Treats
To make treat time even more engaging, use dog-safe peanut butter or its alternatives with treat-stuffing toys. These toys can be filled with peanut butter, yogurt, or other dog-friendly fillings for long-lasting entertainment.
Orbee-Tuff Guru Treat-Dispensing Puzzle Dog Toy
$15.99
The Guru by Outward Hound is a robust interactive dog toy shaped like a ball, featuring five openings to insert treats for a more stimulating playtime. Designed for dogs who love balls and are motivated by treats, it helps combat boredom and enhances snack and play sessions. Once treats are hidden within the openings, your dog must chew, squeeze, and manipulate the toy to access them. Fill each opening with your dog’s favorite spreadable treat for extended fun.
View Details
Dog Tornado Interactive Treat Puzzle Dog Toy, Blue
$19.99 $18.99
The Dog Tornado level 2 interactive dog puzzle from Nina Ottosson is perfect for keeping bored dogs entertained for hours! This intermediate-level toy has three tiers with twelve compartments for dog snacks or kibble. This mentally engaging and fun dog game encourages your dog to spin the puzzle tiers to reveal the treats hidden inside. Three bone-shaped covers can be used to increase the challenge and keep treats concealed.
View Details
Dog Smart Interactive Treat Puzzle Dog Toy, Orange
$16.99 $10.99
The Nina Ottosson by Outward Hound Dog Smart interactive dog puzzle is a fun way to stimulate your dog’s problem-solving skills! This level 1 dog puzzle toy features nine treat-hiding compartments that can be filled with your dog’s favorite treats and covered with bone-shaped pieces. These pieces release the enticing scent of treats through a top opening. Place the toy on the ground and watch your dog use their brain to uncover the tasty rewards hidden inside.
View Details
