For anyone visiting Greenpoint, Brooklyn, a stop at is practically mandatory. This Manhattan Avenue gem has become a true claim to fame for the neighborhood, even capturing the hearts of celebrities like Tina Fey. Featured in documentaries and celebrated on best-of lists reaching as far as Japan, Peter Pan Donuts are more than just a treat; they’re an experience. Beyond their renowned donuts, they offer delightful summer ice cream sandwiches and incredibly affordable prices, with donuts still around $1.10 and a filling meal for under $10. For locals and visitors alike, Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop is a beloved spot for a morning indulgence or a sweet afternoon pick-me-up, constantly evolving with exciting new flavors while retaining its classic charm.
Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop boasts a rich history dating back to the 1950s. However, the current chapter began about 24 years ago when Donna and Christos Siafakas, Greenpoint residents themselves, took over. Donna, a second-generation Greenpointer, learned about the previous owner’s retirement through her aunt, an opportunity that resonated deeply with the couple, who actually met in a Queens donut shop. The transition in ownership was seamless, with Christos stepping into the role of head baker, a position now held by their son Peter. You can often find Donna greeting customers in the mornings, while their other son, Demetri, manages the afternoon and closing shifts, making it a true family affair. This family touch is part of what makes Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop so special.
While Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop initially focused solely on donuts, they have expanded their menu to include sandwiches, offering more options for hungry customers. Despite these additions, much of the shop remains unchanged, including the iconic uniforms that are purchased in bulk due to their discontinued colors. What has changed is the shop’s popularity. Peter Pan is busier than ever, requiring bakers to start as early as 10 PM the night before to meet demand. People travel from far and wide to taste these donuts, with Donna mentioning a family from Dubai as some of their most distant customers. Even with international appeal, Donna still dreams of serving celebrities like Victor Williams and Alec Baldwin.
The introduction of exciting new flavors is largely thanks to Donna’s creativity. Recognizing the desire for variety, she began adding new options to complement the classic glazed and chocolate cake donuts that Peter Pan was known for. The red velvet donut was the first significant addition and quickly became a customer favorite. Now, a rotating selection of “limited edition” flavors keeps the menu fresh and exciting. These include Blueberry Buttermilk, Maple, S’mores, French Toast, Apple Cider Glazed, Apple Cider Cinnamon, Tahitian Cream, and Carrot Cake. Holiday specials like St. Joe’s Day zeppole and Fat Thursday pączki further enhance the seasonal offerings. Not to be overlooked are the Streudels and Christos’ famous Apple Fritters, consistently praised as some of the best in New York City.
Peter Pan Donut and Pastry Shop, located at 727 Manhattan Avenue, is open seven days a week from approximately 5 AM to 8 PM. Whether you’re a Greenpoint local or a visitor to New York City, make sure to experience the magic of Peter Pan Donut & Pastry Shop – a true neighborhood treasure offering delicious treats and a warm, family atmosphere.
