Are Wolfdogs Good Pets? Understanding the Truth

Wolfdogs, a cross between wolves and domestic dogs, present a unique and often misunderstood situation when considered as pets. This comprehensive guide, brought to you by PETS.EDU.VN, will explore the complexities of wolfdog ownership, helping you make an informed decision. Dive into the world of hybrid canines, learn responsible ownership, and discover how to provide the best care with insights available at PETS.EDU.VN, your trusted source for animal companionship knowledge.

1. What Exactly is a Wolfdog?

A wolfdog, also known as a wolf hybrid, isn’t a breed in itself but rather an animal resulting from the interbreeding of a domestic dog (Canis lupus familiaris) and a wolf (Canis lupus). This hybridization creates an animal with a mix of characteristics from both species, leading to a range of physical appearances, temperaments, and behaviors.

1.1. Shared Ancestry, Divergent Traits

Dogs and wolves share a common ancestor and possess nearly identical DNA. This shared genetic heritage explains the physical and behavioral similarities between the two species. However, selective breeding over thousands of years has led to significant differences in temperament, trainability, and social behavior.

1.2. The Individual Nature of Wolfdogs

Each wolfdog is unique, and their individual personalities and temperaments are influenced by several factors:

  • Socialization: Early socialization (between 2-6 weeks of age) is crucial in shaping a wolfdog’s behavior towards humans and other animals.
  • Dog Breeds Involved: The specific dog breeds contributing to the hybrid’s lineage (often German Shepherds, Siberian Huskies, and/or Alaskan Malamutes) influence its temperament and physical characteristics.
  • Wolf Content: The percentage of wolf DNA in the hybrid significantly impacts its behavior, instincts, and overall care requirements.

1.3. Misconceptions and Reality

Wolfdogs are often romanticized in popular culture, leading to misconceptions about their suitability as pets. It’s important to understand that owning a wolfdog is a significant commitment that requires specialized knowledge, resources, and dedication.

2. The Challenges of Wolfdog Ownership

While the allure of owning a wolfdog can be strong, potential owners must be aware of the significant challenges involved. These animals possess unique needs and instincts that can be difficult to manage in a typical domestic setting.

2.1. Escape Artists Extraordinaire

Wolfdogs are notorious for their ability to escape enclosures. Their intelligence and physical capabilities allow them to overcome many common containment methods. They can:

  • Jump over high fences (8 feet or higher).
  • Dig under fences.
  • Figure out how to open doors and gate latches.

Recommended Containment Specifications:

  • Minimum ½ acre enclosure for two animals.
  • 8-foot high fencing (9-gauge chain-link is recommended for sturdiness).
  • Barbed wire lean-in at the top to prevent jumping.
  • Dig guard: 4 feet of fencing buried around the inside perimeter, tied to the bottom rail every 6 inches or concrete along the base of the fence perimeter.
  • Double-gated entry to prevent escapes.

2.2. Socialization and Temperament

Proper socialization is essential for wolfdogs, but even with extensive efforts, they can remain wary of strangers.

  • Skittishness: Wolfdogs not properly socialized early in life (2-6 weeks of age) may remain skittish and fearful of strangers throughout their lives.
  • Guard Dog Myth: Despite their intimidating appearance, wolfdogs do not make good guard dogs. Their natural caution and fearfulness make them more likely to retreat than to confront a threat. However, if cornered or mistreated, they will defend themselves.

2.3. Trainability and Instincts

Wolfdogs possess an independent nature and a strong sense of self-preservation, making them challenging to train.

  • Independent Nature: They lack the inherent desire to please humans that is characteristic of domestic dogs.
  • Untamed Instincts: Even with training, it’s impossible to eliminate their natural instincts completely.
  • Prey Drive: Their natural prey drive can be triggered by small children screaming or small animals running away.

2.4. Social Needs and Destructive Behavior

Wolfdogs are social animals that require companionship. Isolation can lead to destructive behaviors and emotional distress.

  • Need for Companionship: They thrive in the presence of other canines or with constant human interaction.
  • Destructive Behavior: When left alone indoors, they can become destructive, tearing through door frames, drywall, and furniture.
  • Confinement Issues: They typically do not thrive in indoor environments due to their natural inclination to roam and explore. Wolves in the wild roam for miles every day. Captive wolfdogs prefer wide-open spaces and require large enclosures.

2.5. Exercise and Enrichment

Wolfdogs require significant amounts of daily exercise and mental stimulation to prevent boredom and destructive behaviors.

  • Abundant Exercise: They need ample opportunities to run, explore, and engage in physical activity.
  • Mental Enrichment: Providing enrichment activities such as puzzle toys, scent work, and training sessions can help keep their minds stimulated.
  • Boredom Consequences: Lack of exercise and enrichment can lead to digging and other destructive behaviors.

2.6. The “Stealing Game”

Wolfdogs often engage in a behavior described as “stealing.” They take items with their owner’s scent on them and hide them as a form of play or bonding.

  • Scent Association: They are highly attuned to scents and often develop a strong attachment to items that carry their owner’s odor.
  • Hiding Behavior: They hide these items as a way of engaging in a game or asserting dominance.

2.7. Bonding and Separation Anxiety

Wolfdogs often bond strongly with one person, which can create challenges for both the owner and the animal.

  • Single-Person Bond: They typically form a strong bond with one individual, making it difficult for that person to travel or work outside the home.
  • Separation Anxiety: Separation from their bonded person can lead to anxiety, stress, and destructive behaviors.

2.8. Specialized Dietary Needs

Wolfdogs have specific dietary requirements that differ from those of domestic dogs.

  • Raw Meat Diet: They thrive on a diet consisting primarily of raw meat.
  • High-Protein Kibble: If feeding kibble, it must be high-protein and grain-free (no corn, wheat, or soy ingredients).
  • Nutritional Considerations: Their diet must be carefully balanced to meet their specific nutritional needs.

2.9. Veterinary Care Challenges

Finding veterinary care for wolfdogs can be challenging due to liability concerns and lack of experience.

  • Veterinary Reluctance: Many veterinarians do not offer services for wolfdogs due to liability reasons and lack of experience with the species.
  • Specialized Knowledge: Wolfdog health issues and responses to medications can differ from those of domestic dogs, requiring specialized knowledge.

2.10. Rabies Vaccination and Legal Considerations

Rabies vaccination and legal restrictions pose significant challenges for wolfdog owners.

  • No Approved Rabies Vaccine: There is no USDA-approved rabies vaccine for wolfdogs. This poses a serious risk in the event of a bite, potentially leading to euthanasia.
  • Legal Restrictions: Wolfdog ownership is illegal or restricted in many states and municipalities. Before acquiring a wolfdog, it’s crucial to check state and local laws.
  • Shelter Euthanasia: If a wolfdog escapes and is picked up by animal control, it will likely be euthanized since shelters cannot re-home wolfdogs due to liability reasons.

3. Understanding the Statistics

The statistics surrounding wolfdog ownership paint a sobering picture of the challenges and potential outcomes.

3.1. High Relinquishment and Euthanasia Rates

According to the National Wolfdog Alliance, approximately 65% of all wolfdogs end up in a rescue or are euthanized by the age of three. This statistic highlights the difficulties owners face in providing appropriate care for these animals.

3.2. Overburdened Sanctuaries and Rescues

Wolfdog rescues and sanctuaries are often full or overflowing, struggling to accommodate the number of animals in need of care. This lack of resources further exacerbates the challenges of wolfdog ownership.

3.3. The Cycle of Abandonment

Many wolfdogs end up in unsuitable living situations, such as being tied up in backyards due to inadequate containment. Others escape and are taken to shelters, where they face a high risk of euthanasia.

4. Are You Prepared for a Lifelong Commitment?

Wolfdogs have an average lifespan of 12-15 years. Owning a wolfdog is a lifelong commitment that requires unconditional love and dedication.

4.1. Long-Term Considerations

Before acquiring a wolfdog, it’s essential to consider where you will be in 15 years and whether you can provide the necessary care for the animal throughout its life.

4.2. Unconditional Love and Dedication

Wolfdogs offer unconditional love and companionship, but they require the same in return. Owners must be prepared to provide a stable, enriching, and supportive environment for their wolfdog for the duration of its life.

5. Responsible Wolfdog Ownership: A Path Forward

Despite the challenges, some individuals are committed to providing responsible care for wolfdogs. If you are considering wolfdog ownership, it’s crucial to educate yourself thoroughly and take steps to ensure the animal’s well-being.

5.1. Education and Research

Before acquiring a wolfdog, it’s essential to learn as much as possible about the species’ unique needs and behaviors.

  • Consult with Experts: Seek guidance from experienced wolfdog owners, breeders, and rescue organizations.
  • Read Books and Articles: Research the specific care requirements for wolfdogs, including diet, exercise, socialization, and containment.
  • Visit Sanctuaries: Consider volunteering at a wolfdog sanctuary to gain firsthand experience and knowledge.

5.2. Secure Containment

Providing a secure enclosure is paramount to prevent escapes and ensure the safety of the wolfdog and the surrounding community.

  • Follow Recommended Specifications: Adhere to the recommended enclosure specifications outlined earlier in this article.
  • Regular Inspections: Regularly inspect the enclosure for any signs of damage or weakness and make necessary repairs promptly.
  • Consider Additional Measures: Consider adding additional security measures such as electric fencing or motion-activated alarms.

5.3. Socialization and Training

Early and ongoing socialization is crucial to help wolfdogs develop into well-adjusted companions.

  • Early Socialization: Expose the wolfdog to a variety of people, animals, and environments during its critical socialization period (2-6 weeks of age).
  • Positive Reinforcement Training: Use positive reinforcement training methods to teach basic obedience commands and establish a strong bond with the animal.
  • Professional Trainers: Consider working with a professional dog trainer experienced in working with wolfdogs or other challenging breeds.

5.4. Dietary Management

Providing a balanced and appropriate diet is essential for maintaining the wolfdog’s health and well-being.

  • Raw Meat Diet: If possible, feed a diet consisting primarily of raw meat, bones, and organs.
  • High-Quality Kibble: If feeding kibble, choose a high-protein, grain-free formula specifically designed for active dogs.
  • Consult with a Veterinarian: Consult with a veterinarian or animal nutritionist to determine the appropriate dietary plan for your wolfdog.

5.5. Veterinary Care

Finding a veterinarian experienced in working with wolfdogs is crucial for ensuring the animal receives proper medical care.

  • Search for Specialists: Seek out veterinarians who have experience with wolfdogs or other exotic animals.
  • Establish a Relationship: Establish a relationship with a veterinarian before an emergency arises.
  • Discuss Vaccination Protocols: Discuss vaccination protocols with your veterinarian and be aware of the legal implications of rabies vaccination.

6. Alternatives to Wolfdog Ownership

If you are drawn to the unique characteristics of wolfdogs but are not prepared for the challenges of ownership, consider alternative options.

6.1. Wolfdog Sanctuaries and Rescues

Support wolfdog sanctuaries and rescues through donations, volunteering, or fostering. These organizations provide essential care for wolfdogs in need.

6.2. Dog Breeds with Wolf-Like Appearance

Consider owning a dog breed with a wolf-like appearance, such as a Siberian Husky, Alaskan Malamute, or German Shepherd. These breeds offer similar aesthetics without the complexities of wolfdog ownership.

6.3. Education and Advocacy

Educate yourself and others about the realities of wolfdog ownership. Advocate for responsible breeding practices, stricter regulations, and increased support for wolfdog rescues and sanctuaries.

7. The Role of PETS.EDU.VN

PETS.EDU.VN is committed to providing accurate and reliable information about wolfdog ownership and responsible pet care. We believe that education is essential for ensuring the well-being of all animals.

7.1. Comprehensive Resources

PETS.EDU.VN offers a wealth of information on various aspects of wolfdog ownership, including:

  • Care requirements
  • Training tips
  • Health considerations
  • Legal regulations

7.2. Expert Advice

Our team of experienced veterinarians, animal behaviorists, and pet care professionals is dedicated to providing expert advice and guidance to wolfdog owners.

7.3. Community Support

PETS.EDU.VN fosters a supportive community where wolfdog owners can connect with each other, share experiences, and learn from one another.

8. Understanding the Legal Landscape of Wolfdog Ownership

Navigating the legal aspects of wolfdog ownership is critical, as regulations vary significantly across different regions. Ignoring these laws can lead to severe penalties, including fines, confiscation of the animal, or even euthanasia.

8.1. State and Local Laws: A Patchwork of Regulations

Wolfdog ownership is governed by a complex mix of state, county, and municipal laws. These regulations can range from outright bans to permitting ownership under specific conditions.

Key Considerations:

  • Permitting Requirements: Some jurisdictions require permits for owning wolfdogs, often involving inspections of the enclosure and proof of insurance.
  • Containment Standards: Strict standards for enclosure size, materials, and security measures are common.
  • Liability Insurance: Many areas mandate liability insurance to cover potential damages or injuries caused by the animal.
  • Zoning Restrictions: Zoning laws may prohibit wolfdog ownership in residential areas.
  • Breed-Specific Legislation (BSL): Although wolfdogs are hybrids, some BSL may apply based on their wolf content or perceived resemblance to restricted breeds.

Examples of Varying Regulations:

State Regulation
Nevada Legal to own a wolfdog, no permit required.
Connecticut Wolfdogs are classified as regulated animals and require a permit from the Department of Energy and Environmental Protection.
New York State law does not prohibit wolfdog ownership, but local ordinances may apply.
Hawaii It is illegal to import or possess wolfdogs.
Illinois Considered dangerous animals, wolfdogs are prohibited in some municipalities.
Washington D.C Wolfdogs are illegal to keep as pets.

It is the sole responsibility of the wolfdog owner to be aware of changes to state and local laws that may impact the ownership of a wolfdog. You can find a list of state regulations regarding wolfdog ownership.

8.2. The Rabies Vaccination Dilemma: A Legal Gray Area

One of the most contentious legal issues surrounding wolfdog ownership is the lack of a USDA-approved rabies vaccine. This absence creates a precarious situation if a wolfdog bites someone.

The Problem:

  • No Recognized Vaccine: The available rabies vaccines are not specifically approved for use in wolfdogs. Their efficacy is not scientifically established.
  • Legal Consequences of a Bite: In many jurisdictions, a bite from an unvaccinated animal, including a wolfdog, mandates automatic quarantine or even euthanasia for rabies testing, regardless of whether the animal shows symptoms.
  • AVMA and HSUS Stance: Organizations such as the American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) and the Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) oppose approving rabies vaccination due to their concern that it will further promote wolfdog ownership.

Owner’s Precarious Position:

  • Risk of Euthanasia: Despite being vaccinated, a wolfdog involved in a biting incident may still be subject to euthanasia to comply with rabies control laws.
  • Liability Issues: Owners face significant liability if their wolfdog bites someone, especially if the animal is not legally considered vaccinated.
  • Conflicting Advice: Veterinarians may be hesitant to administer rabies vaccines to wolfdogs due to legal and ethical concerns.

8.3. Escaped Wolfdogs: Legal Ramifications and Community Safety

The escape of a wolfdog can trigger a cascade of legal and safety concerns, placing owners at risk of severe penalties.

Potential Consequences:

  • Fines and Imprisonment: Owners may face fines or even jail time if their wolfdog escapes and causes damage or injury.
  • Liability for Damages: Owners are legally responsible for any harm caused by their escaped wolfdog, including property damage, injuries to people or animals, and even emotional distress.
  • Animal Control Action: Animal control agencies have the authority to seize and impound escaped wolfdogs. Due to the risks associated with these animals, euthanasia is a common outcome.
  • Public Safety Risk: An escaped wolfdog can pose a significant threat to public safety, especially in residential areas.

Preventive Measures:

  • Secure Enclosures: Implementing robust containment measures is essential to prevent escapes.
  • Microchipping: Microchipping the wolfdog increases the chances of its safe return if it escapes.
  • Emergency Plan: Developing an emergency plan in case of escape is crucial. The plan should include immediate notification of local authorities and strategies for safely recapturing the animal.

9. Finding Veterinary Care for Wolfdogs: Overcoming the Obstacles

Securing proper veterinary care for wolfdogs presents unique challenges due to a combination of factors, including limited expertise, liability concerns, and regulatory ambiguities. However, with perseverance and proactive planning, owners can find qualified veterinary professionals willing to treat their animals.

9.1. The Reluctance of General Practitioners: Why Many Vets Hesitate

Many general practice veterinarians are hesitant to treat wolfdogs due to several reasons:

  • Lack of Experience: Wolfdogs are relatively rare compared to domestic dogs, and many veterinarians have little to no direct experience treating them.
  • Unpredictable Temperament: The inherent wariness and independent nature of wolfdogs can make them challenging to handle in a clinical setting. The risk of aggression is higher compared to typical domestic dogs.
  • Liability Concerns: Veterinarians face increased liability if they are injured by a wolfdog or if the animal causes damage to their property or other patients.
  • Regulatory Uncertainty: The lack of approved rabies vaccine and the varying legal status of wolfdogs create additional concerns for veterinarians.
  • Drug Dosages and Reactions: Standard drug dosages and treatment protocols for domestic dogs may not be appropriate for wolfdogs. Veterinarians need specialized knowledge to adjust dosages and monitor for adverse reactions.

9.2. Locating Wolfdog-Friendly Veterinarians: Strategies and Resources

Finding a veterinarian willing and able to treat your wolfdog requires a proactive and strategic approach.

Effective Strategies:

  • Networking with Wolfdog Owners: Connect with other wolfdog owners in your area through online forums, social media groups, or local wolfdog organizations. They can provide valuable referrals to veterinarians experienced with wolfdogs.
  • Contacting Exotic Animal Veterinarians: Veterinarians specializing in exotic animals are more likely to have the knowledge and experience to treat wolfdogs.
  • Reaching Out to Veterinary Schools: Veterinary schools often have specialized departments or teaching hospitals that may be willing to provide care for wolfdogs.
  • Consulting with Wolfdog Rescues and Sanctuaries: Wolfdog rescues and sanctuaries typically have established relationships with veterinarians knowledgeable about wolfdog health issues.
  • Asking Local Veterinary Associations: Contact your local veterinary medical association for referrals to veterinarians who treat non-traditional pets.
  • Being Transparent and Proactive: When contacting a veterinary clinic, be upfront about owning a wolfdog. Emphasize your commitment to responsible ownership and your willingness to work with the veterinarian to ensure the animal’s safety and well-being.

9.3. Building a Strong Veterinarian-Client Relationship: Trust and Collaboration

Once you find a veterinarian willing to treat your wolfdog, establishing a strong, trusting relationship is crucial for ensuring the animal receives the best possible care.

Key Elements:

  • Open Communication: Maintain open and honest communication with your veterinarian about your wolfdog’s history, behavior, and any health concerns.
  • Respect for Expertise: Respect your veterinarian’s professional judgment and be willing to follow their recommendations.
  • Active Participation: Be an active participant in your wolfdog’s healthcare. Ask questions, research treatment options, and work collaboratively with your veterinarian to develop a care plan that meets your animal’s specific needs.
  • Preparedness for Appointments: Before each appointment, inform the clinic about your wolfdog’s temperament and any special handling requirements. Consider bringing a muzzle or other restraint device if necessary.
  • Patience and Understanding: Be patient and understanding if your veterinarian needs to consult with other specialists or conduct additional research to properly diagnose and treat your wolfdog.

10. Nutritional Needs of Wolfdogs: Mimicking the Wild Diet

Providing a diet that closely resembles what wolfdogs would eat in the wild is essential for their health and well-being. While domestic dogs have adapted to digest starches and processed foods, wolfdogs thrive on a diet rich in protein, fats, and essential nutrients found in raw prey.

10.1. The Prey Model Diet: Emulating the Natural Food Chain

The prey model diet (PMD), also known as the biologically appropriate raw food (BARF) diet, is based on the principle of feeding wolfdogs whole prey animals or their equivalent parts. This approach aims to replicate the natural food chain, providing a balanced and complete source of nutrients.

Components of a Prey Model Diet:

  • Muscle Meat: Provides protein, amino acids, and essential minerals.
  • Raw Bones: Offer calcium, phosphorus, and other minerals, as well as dental benefits.
  • Organs: Rich in vitamins, minerals, and enzymes. Liver, kidney, heart, and spleen are important components.
  • Fat: Provides energy and essential fatty acids.
  • Small Amounts of Fruits and Vegetables: Offer fiber and antioxidants.

Benefits of the Prey Model Diet:

  • Improved Digestion: Raw food is easier for wolfdogs to digest compared to processed kibble.
  • Enhanced Nutrient Absorption: Raw food contains enzymes that aid in nutrient absorption.
  • Healthier Skin and Coat: Raw fats contribute to a shiny coat and healthy skin.
  • Stronger Immune System: Raw food contains probiotics and antioxidants that support the immune system.
  • Better Dental Health: Chewing on raw bones helps to clean teeth and prevent dental disease.
  • Increased Energy Levels: A biologically appropriate diet provides sustained energy throughout the day.

10.2. Transitioning to a Raw Diet: A Gradual and Safe Approach

Switching a wolfdog from kibble to a raw diet requires a gradual and careful approach to avoid digestive upset.

Transition Steps:

  1. Start Slowly: Begin by replacing a small portion of the kibble with raw meat. Gradually increase the amount of raw food over several days or weeks.
  2. Choose Easily Digestible Meats: Start with easily digestible meats such as chicken, turkey, or rabbit.
  3. Introduce Variety: Once the wolfdog is accustomed to raw meat, introduce a variety of different protein sources, including beef, lamb, pork, and fish.
  4. Add Bones Gradually: Introduce raw bones slowly, starting with soft, edible bones such as chicken necks or wings.
  5. Monitor Stool Consistency: Monitor the wolfdog’s stool consistency closely. Soft stools may indicate that the diet is too rich or that the animal is not digesting the raw food properly.
  6. Consult with a Nutritionist: Work with a veterinary nutritionist or a raw feeding expert to ensure the diet is balanced and complete.

10.3. Supplementation: Addressing Potential Deficiencies

Even with a well-planned raw diet, supplementation may be necessary to address potential nutrient deficiencies.

Common Supplements:

  • Vitamin D: Important for calcium absorption and bone health.
  • Vitamin E: An antioxidant that supports immune function.
  • Omega-3 Fatty Acids: Beneficial for skin and coat health, as well as joint function.
  • Iodine: Essential for thyroid function.
  • Trace Minerals: Zinc, copper, and manganese are important for various metabolic processes.

Considerations:

  • Whole Food Supplements: Whenever possible, choose whole food supplements over synthetic vitamins.
  • Dosage: Follow the recommended dosage guidelines carefully.
  • Veterinary Guidance: Consult with your veterinarian before adding any supplements to your wolfdog’s diet.

FAQ: Addressing Common Concerns About Wolfdogs as Pets

1. Are wolfdogs dangerous?

Wolfdogs can be unpredictable due to their mix of wolf and dog genetics. Early socialization and training are crucial, but their inherent instincts can still pose risks.

2. Is it legal to own a wolfdog?

Laws regarding wolfdog ownership vary by state and local municipality. Always check regulations before considering owning one.

3. What kind of enclosure do wolfdogs need?

They require very secure enclosures with high fences (at least 8 feet) and dig guards to prevent escapes.

4. Can wolfdogs be trained?

They are intelligent but independent, making training challenging. Positive reinforcement methods are most effective.

5. What do wolfdogs eat?

A diet high in raw meat is ideal, mimicking their natural prey. Commercial high-protein, grain-free kibble is an alternative.

6. Are wolfdogs good with children?

Their strong prey drive can be triggered by small children, making them potentially unsafe around kids. Supervision is always necessary.

7. Do wolfdogs make good guard dogs?

No, they are naturally cautious and prefer to retreat rather than confront, making them poor guard dogs.

8. What is the average lifespan of a wolfdog?

Wolfdogs typically live between 12 to 15 years.

9. Why is there no approved rabies vaccine for wolfdogs?

Organizations like the AVMA and HSUS are against rabies vaccination approval because they believe it will support irresponsible ownership.

10. Where can I find more information about wolfdog ownership?

Visit PETS.EDU.VN for detailed guides, expert advice, and a supportive community for wolfdog owners.

Conclusion:

Ultimately, the decision of whether or not a wolfdog makes a good pet is a personal one that should be made with careful consideration and a thorough understanding of the challenges involved. While these animals can offer unique companionship, they require specialized care, secure containment, and a commitment to responsible ownership.

Before acquiring a wolfdog, we encourage you to visit PETS.EDU.VN for comprehensive information, expert advice, and resources to help you make an informed decision. Contact us at 789 Paw Lane, Petville, CA 91234, United States or Whatsapp: +1 555-987-6543. At pets.edu.vn, we are dedicated to providing the knowledge and support you need to ensure the well-being of your animal.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *