Welcome to Peg Leg Pete’s, a renowned seafood destination where the freshest catches of the Gulf meet a vibrant, family-friendly atmosphere. Whether you’re a local seafood aficionado or a visitor seeking an authentic taste of Pensacola Beach, our extensive menu promises a delightful culinary journey. From our famous raw oysters to hearty steaks and Cajun specialties, there’s something to satisfy every palate at Peg Leg Pete’s. Dive into our menu and discover your next favorite dish!
The Oyster Bar at Peg Leg Pete’s: A Raw & Steamed Delight
For oyster lovers, Peg Leg Pete’s Oyster Bar is a must-visit. We pride ourselves on serving the freshest oysters, prepared just the way you like them.
Oyster Shooter – A Must-Try!
Priced at $5.75 / $8.75, our signature Oyster Shooter is the perfect way to kick off your meal. Experience a single raw oyster combined with our zesty bloody mary mix and your choice of beer or vodka. It’s an invigorating and uniquely Peg Leg Pete’s experience.
Raw on the Half Shell
Enjoy the pure, unadulterated taste of the Gulf with our Raw on the Half Shell oysters, available at $11.99 / $17.99. Freshly shucked and served with classic accompaniments, these oysters are a testament to the quality we offer.
Steamed Oysters on the Half Shell
For a slightly different take, try our Steamed Oysters on the Half Shell, also priced at $11.99 / $17.99. Steamed to perfection and served with seasoned garlic butter, these oysters offer a warm and savory delight.
Baked Oyster Sensations – A Peg Leg Pete’s Specialty
Our baked oysters are where culinary creativity meets the sea. Each option is available at $13.99 / $22.99, offering a variety of flavors to explore.
Parmesan Oysters
Indulge in our Parmesan Oysters, baked to a golden brown with garlic butter, bread crumbs, and a generous topping of parmesan cheese. A classic baked oyster that’s always a crowd-pleaser.
Spicy Lafitte Oysters
For those who like a kick, the Spicy Lafitte Oysters are a perfect choice. Finely chopped jalapeños mixed with bacon, cheddar cheese, and our special blend of spices create a flavorful and exciting oyster experience.
Cajun Oysters
Experience the taste of Louisiana with our Cajun Oysters. Topped with a tangy cajun sauce, bread crumbs, and Parmesan cheese, these oysters are a spicy and savory sensation.
Rockefeller Oysters
A timeless classic, our Rockefeller Oysters feature a perfectly seasoned spinach mixture, topped with Parmesan cheese and bacon. Rich, creamy, and utterly delicious.
Buffalo Blue Oysters
Combining two American favorites, our Buffalo Blue Oysters pair Maytag blue cheese crumbles with our signature Buffalo hot sauce and bacon. A bold and unforgettable flavor combination.
Imperial Oysters
For a truly decadent experience, try our Imperial Oysters. Topped with our house-made crabmeat stuffing, covered with Alfredo sauce, and baked to a golden brown. These oysters are a luxurious treat.
Baked Oysters 1/2 & 1/2
Can’t decide? Our Baked Oysters 1/2 & 1/2 option, priced at $23.99, lets you choose six of one kind and six of another from our baked oyster selections. Perfect for sharing and sampling.
The Sampler – Taste the Best of Peg Leg Pete’s Baked Oysters
For the ultimate oyster experience, our Sampler at $24.99 features a curated selection of our favorite baked specialties: Buffalo Blue, Cajun, Parmesan, Rockefeller, Spicy Lafitte, and Imperial. A perfect way to experience the full range of our baked oyster creations.
Appetizers to Start Your Peg Leg Pete’s Meal
Beyond oysters, Peg Leg Pete’s offers a wide array of appetizers perfect for sharing or enjoying on your own.
Cajun Shrimp
Priced at $12.99, our Cajun Shrimp features tender Gulf Shrimp dipped in a spicy batter and fried to a golden brown. Served with a zesty cajun sauce, these shrimp are an irresistible start to any meal.
Cheese Sticks
A classic favorite, our Cheese Sticks ($11.99) are mozzarella lightly fried and served with a rich marinara sauce. Perfect for all ages.
Smoked Yellowfin Dip
Don’t miss our Smoked Yellowfin Dip ($13.99) – a delicious and flavorful dip that’s perfect with crackers or tortilla chips.
Snow Crab Legs
For a truly indulgent appetizer, try our Snow Crab Legs ($15.99). Succulent snow crab steamed to perfection and served with drawn garlic butter.
Blue Crab Claws
A local favorite, our Blue Crab Claws are available flash fried or sauteed in garlic butter ($15.99 / $24.99, when available). Experience the sweet and delicate flavor of fresh blue crab.
Grouper Nuggets
Bite-sized and delicious, our Grouper Nuggets ($12.99) are pieces of grouper breaded and lightly fried. Perfect for sharing or a light bite.
Calamari
Our Calamari ($11.99) is lightly battered and fried to a golden brown, offering a crispy and tender appetizer.
Oysters (Fried)
Enjoy 8 fresh, plump oysters fried to a golden brown for $16.99. A different way to enjoy the fresh taste of oysters.
Grilled Shrimp
Five large Gulf shrimp basted and chargrilled, served with garlic butter and dill sauce for $12.99. A lighter and flavorful appetizer option.
Stuffed Shrimp
Four Gulf shrimp filled with our savory crabmeat stuffing, then broiled and topped with a creamy white sauce ($12.99). A rich and satisfying appetizer.
Classic Shrimp Cocktail
A timeless choice, our Classic Shrimp Cocktail ($12.99) features five jumbo shrimp served with our signature cocktail sauce.
Fries Lafitte
Spice up your appetizer selection with Fries Lafitte ($8.99). French fries topped with finely chopped jalapeños, mixed with bacon and cheddar cheese.
Peg Leg Pete’s Favorites: Main Courses You’ll Love
Our “Favorites” section showcases hearty and satisfying main courses, from seafood to chicken.
Chicken Tenders
Five flash-fried chicken tenders served with french fries, cole slaw, and honey mustard for $15.99. A classic comfort food option.
Chicken Breast
A tender marinated chicken breast, chargrilled and served with rice pilaf, sugar snap peas, and garlic toast ($16.99). Add a second chicken breast for just $3.00 more.
Chargrilled Mahi-Mahi
Fresh dolphin fish basted and chargrilled, served with rice pilaf, sugar snap peas, garlic toast, and dill sauce ($22.99). A healthy and flavorful seafood choice.
Gulf Grouper
Fresh grouper basted and chargrilled, served with rice pilaf, sugar snap peas, garlic toast, and dill sauce ($21.99). Experience the taste of local Gulf grouper.
Stuffed Grouper
Fresh grouper filled with our crabmeat stuffing, baked and smothered in white sauce ($25.99). Served with rice pilaf, sugar snap peas, and garlic toast. For a Cajun twist, substitute Crawfish Julie for white sauce for an additional $2.00.
Large Sea Scallops
Large scallops basted and chargrilled, served with rice pilaf, sugar snap peas, and garlic toast ($25.99). A delicate and delicious seafood entree.
Grilled Gulf Shrimp (Entree)
Ten large shrimp basted and chargrilled, a true Florida treat! Served with rice pilaf, sugar snap peas, garlic toast, and sides of dill sauce and garlic butter ($23.99).
Stuffed Shrimp (Entree)
Large Gulf shrimp filled with our crabmeat stuffing, baked, and topped with white sauce ($25.99). Served with rice pilaf, sugar snap peas, and garlic toast.
Mixed Grill
The ultimate seafood platter for one! Large shrimp paired with fresh Gulf grouper and large sea scallops, basted and chargrilled ($26.99). Served with rice pilaf, sugar snap peas, garlic toast, and sides of dill sauce and garlic butter.
Cajun Specialties at Peg Leg Pete’s
Experience the bold flavors of Louisiana with our Cajun Specialties.
Red Beans & Rice
Cooked with country smoked sausage and served over hot fluffy rice with garlic toast ($14.99). A real Southern comfort food classic.
Cajun Fried Catfish
Alabama farm-raised catfish filets dusted in cajun spices and crisply fried ($16.99). Served with french fries, cream cole slaw, and cajun sauce. A house favorite!
Blackened Grouper
Fresh grouper pan-seared in our signature cajun spices ($22.99). Served with rice pilaf, sugar snaps peas, garlic toast, and cajun sauce.
Steaks – Land Lover Options at Peg Leg Pete’s
For those who prefer turf to surf, we offer premium steaks.
Ribeye
A generous 12oz cut of Ribeye steak, priced at $29.99.
Filet Mignon
An 8oz cut of tender Filet Mignon, available for $32.99.
From the Steamer – Fresh and Flavorful
Enjoy the bounty of the sea steamed to perfection.
Shrimp Platter
Steamed peel-n-eat shrimp served hot with corn-on-the-cob and new potatoes ($17.99). A fun and interactive dining experience.
Snow Crab Legs (Steamer)
One and a quarter pound of succulent snow crab legs, served in a bucket with corn-on-the-cob, new potatoes, and garlic butter ($29.99).
Shrimp and Crab Combo
Steamed shrimp and snow crab legs served with corn-on-the-cob, new potatoes, and garlic butter ($25.99). Everyone’s favorite combination!
Whole Lobster
A one and a half pound Maine lobster served whole with corn-on-the-cob, new potatoes, and garlic butter ($32.99). A truly special occasion meal.
Combo for Two
The ultimate seafood feast for sharing! A one and a half pound Maine lobster, a half pound of steamed shrimp, a pound and a quarter of snow crab legs, corn-on-the-cob, and new potatoes ($65.99). For serious seafood lovers!
Enhance Your Entree – Add-Ons at Peg Leg Pete’s
Customize your meal with these delicious additions.
Signature Crawfish Julie
Add our signature Crawfish Julie to any entree for $6.99.
Lightly Fried Shrimp (Add-on)
Enhance your meal with a side of Lightly Fried Shrimp for $6.99.
Five Grilled Shrimp (Add-on)
Add five Grilled Shrimp to any entree for $10.99.
Three Crab Stuffed Shrimp (Add-on)
Indulge in three Crab Stuffed Shrimp for $8.99.
Four Grilled Sea Scallops (Add-on)
Add four Grilled Sea Scallops to your meal for $10.99.
Snow Crab (Add-on)
Add a Snow Crab cluster to your entree for $12.99.
Mahi-Mahi (Add-on)
Add Mahi-Mahi to your entree for $13.99.
Grouper (Add-on)
Add Grouper to your entree for $10.99.
Whole Lobster (Add-on)
Make it truly special by adding a Whole Lobster to your entree for $25.99.
Side Salad or Fish Chowder
Add a Side Caesar Salad, Garden Salad, or a Cup of Fish Chowder to any entree for just $2.99.
Fried Gulf Specialties – Crispy and Delicious
Our Fried Gulf Specialties are cooked in 100% Cholesterol Free Vegetable Oil and served with creamy cole slaw and french fries.
Shrimp (Fried)
A heaping platter of tender Gulf shrimp hand-breaded and fried golden brown ($19.99).
Oysters (Fried)
A dozen plump select oysters, freshly shucked and fried to perfection ($22.99).
Shrimp & Oysters (Fried Combo)
The best of both worlds! A generous portion of our Gulf shrimp and a 1/2 dozen of our select oysters ($22.99).
Gulf Grouper (Fried)
Fresh, boneless filet lightly battered and crisply fried ($21.99). A local favorite!
Blue Crab Claws (Fried)
Fresh blue crab claws from our local waters, fried to crispy perfection (when available, $24.99).
Combo Platter (Fried)
A sampling of Gulf shrimp, oysters, bay scallops, and grouper ($25.99). This is Florida on a plate! (No substitutions, please.)
Pasta Dishes at Peg Leg Pete’s – Italian Inspired
Served with Garlic Toast, our pasta dishes offer a comforting and flavorful alternative.
Grilled Chicken Pasta
Marinated chicken breast chargrilled and served atop fettuccine with marinara sauce and broccoli florets ($15.99 / $19.99). Substitute alfredo sauce for $3.00 more. Add a second chicken breast for $3.00 more.
Chicken Parmesan
Marinated chicken breast coated with seasoned bread crumbs, then baked in the oven with mozzarella cheese ($16.99 / $20.99). Served over fettuccine marinara. Substitute alfredo sauce for $2.00. Add a second chicken breast for $3.00.
Pegleg’s Marinara Pasta
A generous portion of pasta smothered in marinara sauce ($11.99). Substitute alfredo sauce for $2.00 more.
Pasta with Grilled Shrimp or Grilled Grouper
Fresh Gulf grouper or Gulf shrimp basted and chargrilled, served atop fettuccine smothered in marinara sauce ($17.99 / $21.99 or $19.99 / $22.99 – price unclear in original). Substitute alfredo sauce for $2.00.
Shrimp – Peg Leg Pete’s Signature Style
Our shrimp is a true specialty, fresh Gulf Coast shrimp steamed in beer and Peg Leg Pete’s very own cajun spices. Served cold with cocktail sauce for dipping (U Peel-Um Mates).
1/2 Pound Shrimp (Signature)
Enjoy a half pound of our signature steamed shrimp for $15.99.
1 Pound Shrimp (Signature)
For the serious shrimp lover, a full pound of our signature steamed shrimp for $21.99.
Soups & Salads – Lighter Options
Gumbo
A variety of Gulf Coast seafood & vegetables seasoned with gumbo filé, herbs, and spices ($5.99 Cup / $7.99 Bowl). Served over rice with garlic toast.
Fish Chowder
Creamy New England style chowder with fresh chunks of grouper ($5.50 Cup / $6.99 Bowl).
Key West Salad
Fresh salad greens topped with roasted pecans, raisins, sliced egg, cheese, cucumber, cherry tomatoes, and green onions ($11.99). Served with a tangy dijon vinaigrette. Add Grilled chicken Breast for $13.99, 5 oz Grilled grouper for $15.99, 5 Grilled Shrimp for $15.99, Mahi Mahi Filet for $16.99, or 8 Fried Oysters for $17.99.
Pegleg’s House Salad
Crisp iceberg and romaine blend topped with tomatoes, cucumbers, cheddar cheese, green onions, bacon, and sliced egg ($12.99). Served with your choice of dressing. Add Grilled Chicken Breast for $13.99, 5oz Grilled Grouper Filet for $15.99, 5 Grilled Shrimp for $15.99, Mahi Mahi for $15.99, or 8 fried oysters for $16.99.
Caesar Salad
Classic Caesar Salad ($8.99 / $6.99 – price unclear in original). Add w/Grilled Chicken $10.99, w/Grilled Grouper $14.99, w/5 Grilled Shrimp $14.99, w/Fried Shrimp $10.99, w/Grilled MahiMahi $16.95, or w/8 Fried Oysters $17.99.
Garden Salad
Crisp iceburg Romain blend topped with tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, and choice dressing ($3.99).
Garlic Toast (Side)
Add Garlic Toast to any meal for just $0.50.
Flash Fried Lunch Baskets – Daily Specials (11am – 2pm)
Served with French Fries and Creamy Coleslaw, available daily from 11am to 2pm.
Catfish Lunch Basket
2 Alabama farm-raised catfish filets lightly dusted with cajun spices and crispy fried ($13.99).
Shrimp Lunch Basket
A basket of crispy fried shrimp ($13.99).
Grouper Nuggets Lunch Basket
Bite-sized pieces of Grouper deep fried ($13.99).
Fresh Shucked Oysters Lunch Basket
Eight plump freshly shucked oysters deep fried ($16.99).
Sandwiches – Served with French Fries and Pickle
Grouper BLT
A perfectly seasoned, chargrilled grouper filet with bacon, lettuce, tomato, and Hellmann’s mayo on Texas toast ($14.99).
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Marinated grilled chicken breast served on kaiser bun with lettuce and tomato ($12.99). Add cheese for $0.50 or bacon for $1.00.
Club Sandwich
Thinly sliced turkey breast and ham, bacon, lettuce, American cheese, tomatoes, Hellmann’s mayo, and honey mustard dressing ($13.99).
Fried Shrimp Po’ Boy
A classic Fried Shrimp Po’ Boy ($13.99).
Fried Grouper Nugget Po’ Boy
Served on a toasted roll with lettuce tomato and tarter sauce ($13.99).
Fried Oysters Po’ Boy (Freshly Shucked)
Served on toasted roll with lettuce, tomato, and tarter sauce ($16.99).
French Dip
Roast beef or turkey breast simmered in au jus to perfect tenderness ($13.99). Served with Swiss cheese on a hoagie roll with a side of au jus for dipping. A Peg Legs favorite!
Grouper Sandwich
Enjoy yours fried with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and tartar sauce. Or get it blackened with Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and cajun sauce ($14.99).
Grouper Supreme
A lightly blackened grouper filet chargrilled and served with grilled onions, green peppers, mushrooms, tartar sauce, and smothered with Swiss cheese ($15.49).
Hoagies
Roast beef, turkey, or ham served on a toasted hoagie roll with shredded lettuce, tomatoes, Swiss cheese, Hellmann’s mayo, and our famous Key West dressing ($13.99). Hoagies are served cold, but can be heated upon request. Add bacon for $1.00.
Burgers – Chargrilled Perfection
Served with French Fries, our burgers are made with a half pound of 100% pure ground beef chargrilled to perfection.
Hamburger
A classic Hamburger ($12.49). Add cheese for $0.50 or bacon for $1.00.
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Topped with sauteed mushrooms and Swiss cheese ($13.99).
Cajun Burger
Cajun seasoned and topped with Swiss cheese, sauteed peppers and onions ($13.99). Served with cajun sauce.
Side Orders to Complete Your Meal
Side Dishes
Choose from Sugar Snap Peas, Broccoli, New Potatoes, Small Fries, Corn Cobette, Cole Slaw, Red Beans and Rice, Rice Pilaf, or White rice ($3.75 each).
Large Fries
A generous portion of Large Fries ($3.99). Add Nacho Cheese for $5.25 or Chili & Cheese for $6.25.
Fries Lafitte (Side)
A side portion of our popular Fries Lafitte ($8.99).
Desserts – Sweet Endings at Peg Leg Pete’s
Bread Pudding with Amaretto Sauce
A warm and comforting classic ($7.99).
Key Lime Pie
A taste of Florida sunshine ($7.99).
Peanut Butter Pie
Rich and decadent peanut butter pie ($7.99).
Dessert of the Day
Ask your server about today’s special dessert (price varies).
Beverages – Refreshing Drinks
Bottomless Soft Drinks, Ice Tea, Coffee
Enjoy unlimited refills of Coke, Diet Coke, Sprite, Barq’s Root Beer, Dr. Pepper, Pink Lemonade, Sweet Tea, Unsweet Tea, or Coffee ($2.99).
Milk
A refreshing glass of milk ($2.50).
Bottled Water
Stay hydrated with Bottled Water ($1.99).
Wine Selection
Explore our wine list featuring Pacific Rim Riesling, Mezzacorona Pinot Grigio, Nobilo Sauvignon Blanc, Marrissou Moscato, Kendall Jackson Chardonnay, William Hill Chardonnay, Cambria, Frogs Leap Chardonnay, JamJar Sweet Shiraz, Columbia Valley Merlot, Alamos Malbec, Kendall Jackson Cabernet, Yulupa Pinot Noir, Louis M Martini Cabernet Sauvignon, and House Wines (price varies).
Beer Selection
Choose from Draft Beer options like Bud Light, Coors Light, Miller Lite, Michelob Ultra, Yuengling Lager, Blue Moon, Sweetwater 420, Sam Adams Boston Lager, Sam Adams Seasonal, Peg Leg Pete’s Riptide Amber, and Feature Drafts (ask your server for today’s selections). Bottle Beers include Budweiser, Bud Light, Miller Light, Coors Light, Michelob Ultra, Red Stripe, Heineken, Corona, Corona Light, Stella Artois, Landshark, O’Douls, Angry Orchard Cider, and Truly Hard Seltzer (ask for flavor options, price varies).
Signature Cocktails
Try our signature Shipwreck, Frozen Drinks (Margaritas, Coladas, Daiquiris), Bushwacker, Bimini Mango, Raspberry Swirl, Key Lime Pie (Frozen), Virgin Daiquiris, or Shakes (no alcohol). Frozen Shipwreck also available (price varies).
*All Prices Subject to Change at Any Time*
